Notice: I have written in other languages, many interesting articles that you
can read translated in English
in these links:
Part 1 and Part 2.


ANALYSIS OF THE ASTROLOGY TAUGHT BY HIRAM BUTLER


 
In this regard, the astrologer and theosophist Walter Gorn Old (who used to write under the pseudonym Sepharial) pointed out the following:
 
It is curiously interesting to notice what logically impossible conclusions may be arrived at by one who has just sufficient natural impulse towards occultism to produce in him an overpowering desire for “something novel,” without the necessary mental and intuitive qualifications for investigation. “Over the pond” this craving for “novelties” is rather strong, perhaps more so there than in any other part of the globe; and the effects of this tendency are far too frequently of the nature above indicated.
 
The mental atmosphere of the West is at the present day filled with these “inflated bladders,” which require but the application of a pin’s point —rather more penetrating than over-powering— to destroy their commercial buoyancy. Scientific children are fond of them as toys, but if one more enquiring than the rest should seek to know why they are so floaty and the rest, the result of his enquiry is usually so much wind; and it may be, a little colouring matter inside, serves to give the whole thing an attractive appearance.
 
A copy of The Esoteric, a monthly periodical “of advanced and esoteric thought,” comes to hand, and from a careful perusal of its subject matter, I am inclined to think that it stands first class in colour and size among the many of its kind which I have referred to as “inflated bladders.”
 
One would easily be led to suppose, upon first sight of this publication, from the fair sprinkling of Sanskrit names and references to Oriental literature, that it was the organ of some learned Hindu Samaj. Not at all! It is that of a certain American “Secret Science Association.” Its initial subject is “Solar Biology,” to which frequent references are made, and from which extracts appear month by month.  From an advertisement which fills one page of The Esoteric, it appears that 20 lessons can be had in Solar Biology, “ with written copy,” for 50 dollars!
 
A sample of this new-fangled “science” is contained in the copy of the magazine for November, 1888, the only one from which I am able at present to quote:
 
“Twelve Manner of Genii” is the title of this extract.
 
“The genius of Scorpio— which applies to all persons born between October 23rd and November 22nd.” The theory advanced on this subject is that of every person manifesting certain mental, psychic, and physical peculiarities agreeable to the nature of the Zodiacal sign the sun happens to be in, by geocentric longitude, at birth. An examination of this theory may not prove uninteresting to the readers of Lucifer magazine.
 
The sun is, without doubt, the source of all natural life in its own system, and it is in the modification of this one natural life-principle that characteristics are produced in the forms of life which manifest them. But no allowance is made either for the latitude or longitude of birth in this theory of Solar Biology, and therefore it is to be inferred that, because the geocentric longitude of the Sun is, between the above dates, in the sign Scorpio, all persons born under any conditions and in any clime during that period, will manifest similar tendencies in mind, soul and body. This is rather wide reasoning; for it is a well-known fact that the angular distance which any celestial body may form in relation to a certain place on the earth’s surface, will determine the degree and quality of that body’s influence on persons happening to be born at the time in that place.
 
In this respect the planets, as moderators of the solar rays, will determine the characteristics of the native, according to their relative angular distances in the Zodiac, and their several positions in respect to the place of birth. But “Hiram Butler” thinks differently, and refers all the electric and magnetic effects of the earth and sun (the cosmical father and mother) and all those of the planets in the solar system to the stars which fall within the limits of certain 30 degrees of the Earth’s Zodiac!
 
For if the Sun, by its apparent motion through the Zodiac, alters its nature 12 times in the course of a year, and if its relative angular distance from the place of birth stands for nothing, we must necessarily infer that those changes of the solar action are due to the nature of the constellations with which it is in conjunction “Hiram Butler” evidently has not given sufficient attention to the relationship existing between the fixed or Intellectual Zodiac and the moveable or Natural Zodiac.
 
The stars or constellations which now occupy the sign Scorpio will in 2,160 years have passed into the sign Libra and the stars of our present sign Sagittarius will then be in Scorpio.
 
Will “Hiram Butler” reappear in those days to revise his Solar Biology, I wonder? Or will it perish with him?
 
Speaking of the descent of the elemental thought-forms from the solar aether towards incarnation in the human form, the author says:
 
“All in their degree relate themselves to the elements, first, o f the air, then of fire”! But if it’s all the same to him, suppose we say, “first, to fire, and next to the air,” which happens to be the order of natural descent?
 
Further on our author tells us:
 
“When the sons of Jacob went down into Egypt, Joseph took Simeon (Scorpio), and bound him before their eyes, and sent them back after the youngest son, Benjamin (Virgo), and Simeon remained there until Virgo was brought. Here was mystically symbolized that the sex function must be bound until the intuitional function (Virgo) is brought into the state of scientific knowledge; also the tenacity of the Virgo nature to adhere to the traditions of the fathers.
 
Also:
 
“See Genesis xiv, wherein is expressed a wonderful prophecy couched in the most mystic symbology, only discoverable by a knowledge of Solar Biology.”
 
This sounds very well indeed, but if we consult one or two of our Oriental scholars we shall find that this interpretation is rather strangled and arbitrary. Drummond tells us (vide OEdipus Iudaicus) that the eighth sign of the Fixed Zodiac (Scorpio) is referred to Dan, “the serpent in the path”: and that Virgo the “Isis” of the ancient Hindu Zodiac, representing the procreative faculty, denotes Naphtali, “the spreading oak yielding goodly branches.” (See Genesis, xlix).
 
Altogether I am not much struck with either the method of Hiram Butlei’s reasoning, nor the fanciful conclusions he arrives at.
 
Sepharial.
 
(Lucifer, February 1889, p.517-9)
 
 
 
 
 
 
OBSERVATION
 
Unfortunately many individuals took up the erroneous simplifications that Hiram Butler invented, and these have been incorporated into modern astrology, making its interpretations incorrect.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment