Notice: I have written in other languages, many interesting articles that you
can read translated in English in this
link.

LETTERS FROM FRANZ HARTMANN TO JIRAH DEWEY BUCK




Dr. Jirah Dewey Buck was a homeopathic physician and a prominent leader in the early American Theosophical movement.

Dr. Franz Hartmann met him when he went to the United States in 1897 to give a lecture tour on theosophy in various cities of that country.

They became friends and I will now translate the letters that I have found that Hartmann wrote to Buck, adding my explanations to clarify the events that Hartmann narrates in them.




LETTER OF 1897

« Hallein, October 17, 1897.

My dear Dr. Buck.

I received your delightful letter and thank you very much for the kind sentiments expressed therein. I should also be very glad to send you a baril of Lignosulfot [a medicine invented by Hartmann] free of any charge; but unfortunately I am bound by contract with Mr. Parmele and Dr. Buckman, not to send any either directly or indirectly to America until they have decided what to do about it, by January 1, 1897.

I hope however that you will obtain some by writing to Dr. Buckman, Fort Wayne, Ind. or by addressing Chas. Boone Parmele, 36 Platt Street, New York.

Here we have wonderful and often entirely unexpected success with it. The worst cases of eczema are cured by washing with L.s. and a patient at the inhalatorium whowes blind on one eye, while inhaling for his bronchial catarrh, unexpectedly recovered his sight. Professor Leyden of Berlin highly recommended it at the medical congress at Moskau, and now everything promises to go well.

I received a letter from a friend of yours from Denver, and advised him to write to Parmele. I am now getting ready to lecture on Theosophy in Austria and Germany and next week I will lecture at Vienna. If the L.s. Comp. gets started in America, I hope to see you next year. I shall then, I hope, not be "managed" by Mr. Willard but manage myself.


I am having a great deal of trouble with this Theosophical Society business in this country, owing to the continued fussing and fighting about the superiority of Mrs. Tingley or Mrs. Besant, and am sick of this presideney and sick of all partisanship.

I wish we could have in Germany a real Theosophical Society based upon the recognition of truth, and not founded merely upon a belief in the superiority of this or that person. For this reason I have started an International Theosophical Brotherhood (without knowing anything about Mrs. Tingleys similar scheme). This I.T.B. to be the large circle to which everybody may belong, whether he believes in Tingley or Besant, the inner circle to be the active members of the Theosophical Society  in Germany.

This I.T.B. to be free in the administration of its own affairs from any foreign Society.
This seems to have been misunderstood by Mrs. Tingley and Neresheimer, as if I wanted a separation from the T.S. in A., although I expressly declared my adherence to the T.S. in A. at our convention. So Mrs. T. & N. sent a "protest", which shows a quite sectarian spirit, and by which they have made a bad impression in Germany.

I prefer to say nothing about it, and to let matters take their own course; but I thought it well, to inform you about the state of the matter. 

I wish to the T. S. in A. the greatest possible financial success, and I gave to Mr. Pierce and Mrs. Tingley a large share in the Lignosulfot Co. for that purpose; but I should be sorry if the people in that country should get the impression that the T. S. in A. was a mere money-making scheme.

Elease give my love and regards to your family, If you have time to write, I should be very glad to hear from you. My permanent address is for the present Hallein in Salzburg, Austria.

Later on I return to Florence.

Yours Faithfully
Dr. F. Hartmann »




Observations

After Blavatsky died in 1891, the Theosophical Movement had three great leaders:

      -  William Judge in America.

      -  Annie Besant in Europe.

      -  And Colonel Olcott in Asia.


Unfortunately, shortly afterwards Besant and Olcott joined forces to expel William Judge, and the result was that in 1895 the Theosophical Society split into two organizations:

    1)   The Theosophical Society of America led by William Judge and

    2) The Theosophical Society of Adyar led by Olcott and Besant.      


William Judge died shortly after this breakup, and Katherine Tingley became the new president of the Theosophical Society of America.

She appointed Hartmann president of the German section of the Theosophical Society of America, and Hartmann had to deal with the confrontation between the supporters of Tingley and the supporters of Besant.

Fed up with this situation, Hartmann created the "International Theosophical Brotherhood" organization, which was intended to not take part in these partisan disputes and to include both sides, but the result was that both sides became angry with him.

Sadly, both Besant and Tingley did a lot of damage to the Theosophical Movement.






POSTCARD FROM 1898

« Gruss aus Hallein. January 14, 1898.

Dr. J.:

Accept my congratulation to the success of the Chicago convention. I am very glad that you have been elected. I hope that in this country too harmony will be restored before long. With my sincere regards, to you and your family.
Yours truly,

F.H. »







LETTER OF 1900

FRANZ HARTMANN, MD
VILLA MERCEDES, BELLO SGUARDO
FIRENZE


« Florence, Jan 9, 1900.

My dear Dr. Buck:

Many thanks for your kind and interesting letter. I do not understand why your letter to Hallein has not reached unless you addressed it to Hullein which is another place. There are however two Halleins in Austria.


I have been very much interested in what you wrote me about Hilarion and the Lodge in Syracuse, and I should, as a matter of course, be very glad to participate in it, but as I am here in Europe, this would perhaps be somewhat difficult.

I suppose that my participation will have to be a spiritual one and consist in harmonious thought and sympathy. Any paper that you will send, will however be welcome and kept secret.


I to have heard nothing more of the E.S. [Esoteric Section] of which Charles Johnstone seems to be the "outer head", and I do not know whether I belong to any "esoteric section" except my own, which is presided over by my inner consciousness.

It always seems me that each "esoteric Society", as soon as it steps on the external plane, become exoteric, and then follows sectarianism and intolerance, such as is exhibited by the members of the Tingley and Besant persuasion.

The latter have gone so far as to warn my own most intimate friends against me and prohibit them from reading my books. There is only one all saving Theosophical Society, whose president is Capt. Bumptious [Olcott], and whose oracel is Mrs. Besant.

Last year I gave a lecture at Nice (France) with great success, but none of the Besant people were permitted to attend, the Countess Wachtmeister would not allow it, although I and my friends have come to her lecture (which was a very poor one).

Last night I gave a lecture in Italian language in Florence, and had a very nice audience; but Mrs. Cooper-Oakley warned her adherents to attend, and thereby she disgusted her own best followers, who thereupon left her society.

Is to in it to be wondered, when under such circumstances I am disgusted with all this childish nonsense and "Theosophical Society business"?

I prefer to deal with sensible people, who do not belong to anything except to themselves, fooling with society fanatics, who consider everyone their enemy, if he does not cling to the coat tails of the same person as they.

There is not one person a hundred ripe for entering a real esoteric society, nevertheless we have now a lot of such bodies assuming that name, and consisting of curiosity hunters each of which desires to ursurp the leadership in the T.S., while in fact the T.S. requires no other leader, but the light of truth, and ought to remain, what always was intended to be, a body for free investigation of the laws which govern the universe.

Practically the efforts of Mrs. Besant and Mrs. Tingley have been to turn the whole T.S. into an "esoteric Society", each under her sole leadership, and thus they have succeeded in turning it into one great insane asylum, where the brothers and sisters heartily hate and despise each other if they do not belong to the same party.


I have succeeded to form quite a number of theosophical societies on the original plan in Germany, Austria and Hungaria, but I am adverse to bringing them under one hat, because I wish to avoid all tendency to sectarianism and prefer that each society should be independent and stand on its own legs. For the same reason I have refused all offers to be elected president.

I agree that each esoteric society must have as leader a spiritually elevated person, with whom all the members ought to be as one in thought and aspiration, so that he may carry them up with him into the regions of knowledge, and for this reason a disciple cannot have more than ome master. No one can at the same time go two different ways.

But all this has nothing to do with the T.S. because the T.S. is no esoteric society and not a school for occultism, but a preparatory school in which each member should first of all try to learn to find his own real self. If he has found himself, he will not have far to go to for a master for aid and instruction.

With all this, I cannot say that I regret or deplore all this strive and discension in the T.S. I do not pretend to be wiser than the law of Karma, which has ordered it and which leads everything to the best end.

Nothing has done so much to call the attention to the theosophical teachings as the opposition of the missionaries and the slader of the Society of Psychical Research. From opposition grows strength.

Let the members of the T. S. become so much sectarian as they please; there are always some who will get experience and outgrow their sectarianism in time, and they are the only ones which are worth having. I should be glad if these views should become known.

Please give my love and regards to your family and to our friends in Syracuse.
I shall always be glad to hear from you.

Yours very sincerely,
F. Hartmann


Postscript: I have not received the "Forum" last month. »




Observations

In this letter, Hartmann explains how those two factions became increasingly sectarian and adversarial. But what Hartmann failed to realize was that the group led by Besant was increasingly straying from the original teachings due to the lies that Alfred Sinnett and Charles Leadbeater were introducing.


As for the Esoteric Section, it was a parallel school to the Theosophical Society, which Blavatsky had created to give a preliminary start to theosophists who wanted to become disciples of the Masters in the future.

But unfortunately, after Blavatsky's death, Annie Besant increasingly altered this esoteric school until it became a complete farce.










ALFRED SINNETT'S POSTHUMOUS TRIBUTE TO BLAVATSKY

 


(When Blavatsky died, Mr. Alfred Sinnett wrote the following text as a posthumous tribute to her.)



A WORD FROM MR. SINNETT

I have been writing about Madame Blavatsky at considerable length for an other periodical [the indian newspaper 'Pioneer' but that was a long time ago] and have thus en deavoured to convey to the exoteric public some idea of the grandeur of the work she has been carrying on in the life just closed.

Invited to contribute some remarks concerning my long friendship with her to the magazine she herself founded, I prefer now to avoid any direct repetition of external impressions concerning her wonderful attributes and faculties, and to deal instead with hints I have received from herself, and in other ways, from time to time, as to the probable course of her own evolution in the future.

For many years past she has spoken to me at intervals of the hopes she entertained in reference to the destinies in store for her when permitted to lay down the burden of the incarnation now exhausted.

All theosophists who have profited by the illumination she was able to shed upon the principles go verning individual human progress, will realise two conclusions about her as practically certain. The life just over can not have been that in which she first began her occult career, and it will certainly not be followed by a normal return in her case to an ordinary period of devachanic rest.

She must have been considerably advanced in preparatory initiation before she becam e H.P.B., and the hard and faithful work she has now been performing for so many years in the service of those who are never ungrateful, will mean inevitably that kind of reward which will best subserve her further spiritual progress.

I do not know how far she may have elucidated the matter to others, but I see no reason for reticence in regard to her more recent incarnations; in reference to which, indeed, she never gave meany details, and led me to believe that she was un acquainted with details. But as to the broad fact I have no personal doubt.


Her very last incarnation before this one just completed was in the person of a member of her own recent familly, an aunt who died prematurely; and that existence does not seem to have served her advancement in any important degree.

Before that she had been a Hindoo woman of considerable occult attainm ents, with eager hopes and aspirations concerning the people to whom she then belonged.

Her transfer to another nation a lity seems to have been connected in some way with a belief on her part that she would be better able from the fulcrum of a European birth to further the interest of the Hindoo race.


As regards the future —or may we say as regards the present?— it seems very unlikely that she would have another female incarnation in succession to her last. The highest teaching has been to the effect that alternations occur in almost all cases after a short series of incarnations in the same sex.

Her own wish in this matter pointed very strongly to a masculine incarnation this time, and her expectation that this wish would be realised was very confident.

Many readers of 'Lucifer' [magazine] will be aware that the abnormal incarnations of those whose Karma has lifted them above the operation of automatic laws are of two kinds.

1) The Chela-Ego [the soul of a disciple] may be linked with a newly form ingorganism, and be born as a child in the ordinary way — though destined in such a case to recover recollection of the previous life as soon as the new body should attain maturity.

2) Or it may be transferred with violence, so to speak, to an already mature body, adapted to serve as a vehicle for its further manifestations and progress, if such a body happens to be ready at the right moment; that is to say if its former tenant happens to be provided for in some other way.

To meet such an pportunity as this it would be necessary that the right moment should be seized for effecting the transfer, and it might be expected therefore that any one in whose interest such a transfer was to be accomplished, would be called at a moment’s notice, would in conventional language, die very suddenly.

Now it is a striking fact about Madame Blavatsky's “death” that ill as she often has been of late, and impossible though it might have been to have kept her organism in activity much longer, she was physically better on the day she died than she had been for several days previously, and was congratulated that morning by her doctor on having got over the attack she had been troubled with.

Her death just when it occurred was an absolutely unexpected event, and could probably not be assigned to any specific physical cause. On two or three occasions during the last half dozen years she has been definitely given over by her doctors and declared incapable o flivin g another day.

In such crises she has been rescued at the last moment, evidently by the exercise of occult power; whereas on the present occasion, when there was no apparent need for her to die at all, she closes her eyes and passes a way in an instant.

To me the inference seems very plain and points among other conclusions to the possibility that the new personality she may now have been clothed with, if already mature, may in the progress of events be identified by some of us now living before we in turn are called upon — or permitted — to use which ever phrase best suits our internal condition of mind — to pass through the great change ourselves.

(Lucifer, June 1891, pp. 285-287; In Memory of HPB, pp. 21-23)






OBSERVATIONS

Mr. Sinnett's friendship with Blavatsky had faded when she went to live in London in 1887. This cooling is evident from the brevity of his posthumous tribute to Blavatsky.

I find it in very bad taste that instead of honoring Blavatsky, he started speculating about her past reincarnations and her next rebirth, several of which are erroneous, as I will detail in another article.

It is clear that Blavatsky's close associates pressured him to write something about her, and since he did not want to commemorate her, he preferred to reveal what he had discovered about her in his spiritualist sessions.








ANNIE BESANT'S POSTHUMOUS TRIBUTE TO BLAVATSKY


(Blavatsky died on May 8, 1891, and Annie Besant wrote the following text to honor her teacher.)



AS I KNEW HER

"Endurance is the crowning quality.
And patience all the passion of great hearts."
Lowell.


Endurance and patience have certainly been the crowning qualities of H P B. as I have known her during the last years of her life, and as I have heard of her from those fortunate enough to have known her for more years than I can count during her present life.

The most salient of her characteristics was implied in these crowning qualities; it was that of strength, stead y strength, unyielding as a rock. I have seen weaklings dash themselves up against her, and then whim per that she was hard.

But I have also seen her face to face with a woman who had been her cruel enemy —but who was in distress and, as I uncharitably thought, therefore repentant— and every feature was radiant with a divine compassion, which only did not forgive because it would not admit that it had been outraged.

The hardness which can be tender is the hardness which is needed in our mollient Western life, in which one is sick of the shams that pass for value, of the falseness that stabs with a smile, and betrays with a kiss. Unconventional, H.P.B. was always called, and the adjective was appropriate. She did not regard society conventions as natural laws, and she preferred frankness to compliment.

Above all she had the sense of proportion, and that “rarest sense of all, common sense”.

She did not think that all natural piety was trampled under foot when a woman smoked cigarettes, nor that every bond which held society together was ruptured when some solecism in manners was committed. A traveller in many lands, she had seen social customs so various that one or another was to her as unimportant as wearing a hat, a turban, or a fez, and she laughed at all the crude insular British ideas that a man’s merit depended on his agreement with our own notions.

On the other hand, she was rigidity itself in the weightier matters of the law; and had it not been for the injury the writers were doing themselves by the foulnesses they flung at her, I could often have almost laughed at the very absurdity of the contrast between the fraudulent charlatan and profligate they pictured, and the H.P.B. I lived beside, with honour as sensitive as that of the “very gentil parfait knyghte”, truth flawless as a diamond, purity which had in it much of a child’s candour mingled with the sternness whicli could hold it scatheless against attack.

Apart from all questions of moral obligation, H.P.B. was far too proud a woman, in her personality, to tell a lie. Brought up amid the highest born of the Russian nobility, inheriting much of their haughty contempt for the people around them, she would not have condescended to justify herself by untruth; she did not sufficiently care for “what people would say” to stoop to any subterfuge to defend herself.

Indeed some of the earlier slanders took their rise in this very recklessness of public opinion. And when to this was added the occult training that hardens the chela against all outside judgments, and placing him ever at the tribunal of his Higher Self renders him indifferent to all lesser condemnation, it will readily be seen that the motives to untruthfulness which move ordinary people were absent.

And this is apart from the deeper facts of the case, of which it would be idle here to speak, and of which it must suffice to say that no high Occultist can dare to lie for personal gain or personal defence.


It used to be said that the devil paid his servants well in this life, in whatever fashion he might recover the debt in another ; but verily if, as the pious say, she was one of his emissaries, the gold mines of Sheol must be giving out. For in these later days H.P.B. was a very poor woman, and I have known her hard pressed for a sovereign many a time.

Then some devoted admirer would send her money, and away it went, to the Theosophical Society, to a distressed friend, to an old servant in want, to some family whose starvation I might have mentioned.

It was a royally generous nature, that of H.P.B., always needing some channel into which it might flow over ; money, clothes, jewels, anything she had, she flung it away with both hands to the first who was in want.


Looking at her generally, she was much more of a man than a woman. Outspoken, decided, prompt, strong-willed, genial, humorous, free from pettiness and without malignity, she was wholly different from the average female type.

She judged always on large lines, with wide tolerance for diversities of character and of thought, indifferent to outward appearances if the inner man were just and true.

Personally, one of the greatest services she rendered me was placing at my service as an aid to self-knowledge her own deep insight into character. I have laughed to myself when I have heard folk say that “Madame Blavatsky must be a very bad judge of character, or she would never have trusted people who afterwards betrayed her”.

They did not know that her rule was to give every one his chance, and she never recked if in thus doing she ran risk of injury to herself. It was always herself she gave away to such persons — never the Society, nor any knowledge they could use to the injury of others.

I watched the course of one such case, a young Judas who pretended friendship, who was admitted by her to stay in her house, who tried ineffectively to find out “secrets”, and went away finally to attack her and try to betray.

She talked to him freely enough, hindered him in none of his enquiries, tried to lead him the right way, but once or twice I caught those strange eyes of hers, of which so much has been said, looking him through with a deep pathetic gaze, turning away at last with a half-breathed sigh.

But when anyone was really seeking that most difficult of all knowledge, self-knowledge, then she would use her rare power of insight, would warn of hidden dangers, point to concealed characteristics, unravel the tangled threads of half-understood or non-understood qualities and defects, and thus guide the student in his efforts to know himself, and to escape from the web of illusion.

Over and over again, in my own case, she has led me straight to hidden motive, to concealed weakness, to covered pitfall, and any of her pupils who could bear her scrutiny and criticism without resentment might be sure of similar aid.


As teacher H.P.B. was inspiring and suggestive, not didactic. She could only teach effectively when the student was thoroughly in touch with her, and could fill with quick intuition the gaps she left in her outline.

In such cases she would throw out thought after thought, with wonderful wealth of illustrations from the most widely separated sources, the thoughts often unrelated on the surface, but always found, on careful re-study after wards, to be links thrown, as it were, into light of some unbroken chain.

The intervening links had been left in shadow, and if the student could throw them also into light, by the use of his own intuition, it was well. But where the student’s mind gave no response to hers, where her quick blows startled no spark to leap forth in answer from the rock, to such H.P.B. remained always enigmatic, obscure, involved, lost in maze of metaphysics, and she proved as unsatisfactory to them as they were hopeless to her.


Of late, H.P.B. led a very secluded life; she would close her doors for days, sometimes for weeks, against those who were nearest to her, and we understand now how she was preparing all for the approaching change [her death].

And to us who lived with her the change is less than many, perhaps, may suppose. Our nearness to her was not that of the bodily presence, it was that far closer tie which ever binds together teacher and pupil in the venerable philosophy which it was her mission to impart.

To us, the mere fact that she has flung off the worn-out garment of her personality in no wise alters the relation between her and us; those of us who were with her in past lives have been separated physically before through “the change that men call death”, and have found each other again on return to “life” on earth.

What has been shall be, and in the true life no separation is possible. For many a year past, her life has been one long torture; she stood at the centre of a whirl of forces spiritual and psychic, exposed at the same time to the pressure of the material plane.

Alone, with none who could wholly understand her, misunderstood, wronged, insulted, and even when loved mostly loved in a mistaken way, none except her peers can tell what a hell upon earth her life has been. That she is out of it, is matter for rejoicing, not for sorrowing for those who really loved her, not themselves in her.

The work to which she gave her life is now ours to carry on; the forces behind it are not weakened because H.P. Blavatsky has departed.

It is the work of the Brotherhood, not of any one individual, and while the Brotherhood lives and works neither doubt nor despair can touch their disciples. We have but to do our duty: success, as the world counts it, is a thing of no account.


(Lucifer, June 1891, pp. 292-295; In Memory of HPB, pp. 28-31)









THE OBJECTIVES OF THE THEOSOPHICAL SOCIETY DESCRIBED BY FRANZ HARTMANN

 





THE THEOSOPHICAL SOCIETY IN GERMANY

The purpose of the Theosophical Society is: to form the basis of a general brotherhood of humanity.

The following is useful for this: The study of old and new religious systems, philosophy and science, as well as the research and development of the dormant and largely unknown (occult) spiritual powers in humans.

The Theosophical Society not only aims at a general human fraternity, but it represents this fraternity itself, freed from everything that does not belong to its essence. It is therefore not an association that stands on the same level as other associations that pursue this or that special interest, but its ideal, which it strives to realize, is the unification, ennobling and true enlightenment of the entire human race.

But not by the introduction of a new idolatry for some new dogma, or by the erection of the idol of some new “authority,” but by that approach to the knowledge of eternal truth which springs from mankind’s surpassing love of divinity.

Accordingly, the Theosophical Society is large enough to accommodate, like humanity, all societies and associations striving for true progress, and every human being to whom the ennoblement of humanity seems desirable is spiritually, already, without seals and diplomas a member of this theosophical society.

Those who also belong to it formally and externally differ from other noble-minded people only in that they have connected themselves externally; not to gain any personal advantage by it, but to do more good by their combined efforts than they could do if each were acting alone.

The one great bond that not only unites all mankind, but holds all worlds together, is not a scientific theory, nor a philosophical conclusion, but love, which springs from the realization of the Oneness of the essence of all creatures.

Hitherto theories and dreams have been the basis of our cultural states; now the world is beginning to wake up from its slumber and see that social enthusiasm is not enough to make the world a better place. The basis of present-day civilization is supposed to be the love which springs from knowledge and is realized through deeds.


Leoline Wright (crusader) spoke the following words at the first convention of the Theosophical Society in Berlin:

« The great message that Theosophy (not just through the ‘Theosophical Society’ but through a hundred different means) brings to the whole world is love.

We believe and recognize that love is not a mere quality or sentiment, but an all-moving spiritual force, and that without this force as the basis of civilization there can be no true and enduring progress and ennoblement.

The cultural conditions of past centuries have perished because they were built on a destructive force, the principle of selfishness and egoistic ambition. If we wish to make our civilization and our peace lasting, we must replace this all-destructive power of selfishness with the all-perpetuating power of love.

In every single human being there is the ability to unfold this divine power. The energy of love is not a figment of the imagination, but is as real and effective as the electric power produced by a dynamo.

There is a spark of her in everyone’s heart. Whoever lives in this power of love, which is above all self-delusion, and lets it flow unceasingly to all other beings, will not only always live in peace with himself, but also spread happiness, blessings and harmony everywhere a person goes.

Men have made themselves miserable and dissatisfied by ignoring or denying this redeeming power of divine love, and seeking only the gratification of their own or special interests.

We should take nature as an example. The birds in the air, the trees in the forest, the flowers in the field, they don’t care what tomorrow will bring them, but man is always concerned about his dear self; he lives in constant fear of the future, and is never satisfied so long as he desires.

As a rule he lives outside himself and is always anxious to transform his external circumstances to his own advantage and to obtain new means of satisfying new desires. Therefore he seeks to make the whole world and his fellow men a tribute to his selfishness. He analyses, puts together, invents, changes. He lives in things that are outside of him and loses himself in them.

We will only find true happiness when we return more to the simplicity of nature and live in our own divine I, which is the One I, rather than in the ephemeral outside world and is the true essence of all creatures.

Whoever recognizes this one eternal self recognizes God; he recognizes his own divine nature and is elevated above his earthly constitution. He is no longer touched inwardly by what concerns his personality. He lives in the love that unites him with everyone.

This is the great message which Theosophy proclaims to us. Man is a divine being at heart, and when he strives to do good, a divine power emanates from him, which spills over everything. Without this active power of divine love, nothing that is actually and lastingly good can be created. But when it reaches its full development in man, the divine ideal is thereby realized in him, and man himself becomes a redeemer of mankind. »


The sole purpose of The Theosophical Society, therefore, is to give access to that true love which springs neither from ignorance, folly, or mere sentimentality, nor from selfish lust for possessions, but from true spiritual knowledge.

Whoever recognizes his own true divine nature need not first ask why he should treat other creatures lovingly; he sees manifestations of his own divine nature in all other creatures, he sees himself in all others.

In order to arrive at this true self-knowledge it is necessary to eliminate all prejudices and erroneous opinions as to the true nature of man, his position in the universe, his physical, psychic and spiritual nature, etc., and for this purpose the study of the old and new religious systems, philosophy and science.

This study is not its own purpose; it is not a question, as many believe, of satisfying scientific curiosity, or of forming an opinion as to which of the many conflicting authorities is right, but rather of discovering the kernel of truth which is inherent in all major systems of religion and philosophies, to free him from the clinging shell of superstition or formalism, and thereby to get to know the way to Self-knowledge.

There are many who are always looking for mysteries in outward things, but they do not find the best. The greatest secret is man himself, and one’s own self-knowledge is the key to all other mysteries. Anyone who does not recognize his true self in himself sees nothing else in other people than their personalities, and he judges them according to this view.

But the man who really knows himself knows that just as his own person is only his vessel and tool, so the personalities of all other people are to be distinguished from their spiritual individuality. From the confusion of the personality with the “inner man,” who has attained complete spiritual individuality only in those who have come to self-knowledge, arises the wrong judgment of others, spitefulness and sniffing and egoism with its entourage.

Mere research alone is not enough. It is not just a question of knowing, but of acting. For this reason a third paragraph was added to the constitution of the Theosophical Society when it was founded, namely, the actual development of the forces dormant in human nature.

This third item was later removed because it led to the misconception of many that the members of the TG wanted to study magical and occult arts, witchcraft, etc.

In fact, however, the development of spiritual powers only means the unfolding of those powers which must be revealed in every human being if his striving for self-knowledge is not to remain just a wish, a dream, a theory. Above all, these forces include the awakening of true self-awareness and divine love.

The bungler in the Occult Sciences seeks to satisfy his curiosity as to occult powers which he thinks others have possessed, and to inquire how, through external means, he comes, or how he acquires, the possession of magical powers could be usef if he had them; but the magical power is an inward power, which cannot be acquired externally, which becomes manifest in us when we attain self-knowledge.

If you want to have an impact from afar, you have to rise above the limits of your egoism; he who wishes to overcome the resistances of external nature by his mind, his mind must be strong enough to master the resistances of his own [lower] nature, his own animal instincts, selfish desires and passions, and to make them serve his higher ends.

Self-mastery is, however, a great art, and the power required for it is of a “magical” nature, i.e., of a psychic-spiritual nature, and like all spiritual powers, self-consciously, but should be acquired practically and practiced constantly; even at the risk of appearing in the eyes of fools as a sorcerer.

Precisely because the purpose of the Theosophical Society is such a high one, and the principle which animates it, is large enough to encompass all mankind, this purpose is also understood by very few people and even among the members there are many who have only a vague idea of ​​it.

Human nature is not immediately changed by reading an “F.T.S.” (acronym of Fellow of the Theosophical Society) attached to his name. To understand what Theosophy is, one must possess a certain degree of knowledge of God oneself, and be able to discern the eternal and imperishable from the temporal and perishable.

But such persons are to be found everywhere in the minority in our age.That is why it is also the case that in the Theosophical Society and in all other associations there are people who do not know love and are therefore particularly concerned with their own advantage, be it that they would like to “play a part,” or that they believe they can come into possession of secrets inaccessible to other mortals.

Such persons should remember that the beginning of true knowledge begins only when man begins to see that in reality he knows nothing; that all his alleged knowledge relates only to the appearance of things, but not to the en true essence, and that true knowledge is the self-knowledge of truth, which naturally belongs to none other than God, the truth.

The beginning of Theosophy, i.e., “divine self-knowledge” is divine love. Where this does not exist, there can be no knowledge of God, there is no Theosophy. That is why those people who are concerned only with knowledge understand the essence of theosophy least of all. They are busy figuring out what this or that person thinks and whose opinion they should accept as true, and where there are so many considerations there is no room for free thinking.

However, freedom of thought is the indispensable condition for attaining true knowledge and the resulting freedom of will, which raises man above the level of the animal kingdom. As long as man is tied to his own deceptive “self” and his thoughts, wills and actions are guided by his instincts, wishes and desires, he is not free. There is no true freedom but liberation from the delusion of self.

For this reason the message that Theosophy proclaims to the world is not only a message of love but also of freedom. It proves that man is bound by nothing and suffers from nothing but his own “self,” which in itself is nothing, a mere idea.

Anyone who overcomes this delusion is a theosophist and attains mastery over himself. Whoever is master of himself does not need to serve anyone else; he is lord of all, for he is one with God, who is the lord and essence of all.

What would being be without knowledge? What would space be without the light? What would heaven be without love?

She is the soul of everything. Anyone who remains true to this principle is a real theosophist.

(Lotusblüten 8, no. 50, November 1896, pp. 786-799)








 

SOULLESS INDIVIDUALS EXAMINED BY FRANZ HARTMANN

 




THE SPIRITUALLY DEAD


“Dying” is the loss of the ability to know.”

From time immemorial the problem of immortality has stirred hearts and troubled minds; innumerable books have been written on the subject, and there is scarcely a man on earth who has not already asked himself: “What shall become of me when my body crumbles to dust and ashes?”

However, nothing is easier than answering this question, if only we listen to the voice of reason.

We know very well that our physical visible body (Sthūla Śarīra) is not immortal, for we see daily our own kind, friends and relatives, being swept away by death.

We also know that our intellectual functions, opinions and memories are not immortal, because they often change during life on earth and many an intellectual giant has already become a helpless fool in his old age.

From this it follows with certainty that not all which is ordinarily regarded as belonging to man is immortal, and the question is therefore reduced to whether there is anything immortal in man, and, if so, what is its essence.

It goes without saying that the answer to this question cannot be solved by means of objective observation alone, because everything that we can objectively observe are appearances (māyā), they belong in the realm of deception, are temporary and prove nothing more than the existence of what they are, namely appearances and nothing more.

Even if a million apparitions from the spirit world came to us claiming to be the spirits of dead people, all that could prove to us was that there was something involved that was left of certain people, not quite dead and is still connected with life on earth.

Even if a man who had become a god descended from heaven and, if that were possible, brought us the proof of his immortality, this would prove nothing more than that this man had become immortal; but that does not mean that we ourselves are immortal.

Anyone who wants to find proof of immortality must get to know the immortal being within himself; there is no other way. The one in whom the consciousness of his immortality has awakened, who is self-aware of his immortal nature, needs no further proof of it. He is immortal because he is aware of it, and he is aware because he is.

An immortality of which one is not aware would be an “unconscious immortality,” an absurdity and could not be of any use to anyone, because the unconscious matter is also immortal, but it knows nothing about it.

All the theories and experiments brought along the same lines with spiritism, psychism, experimental occultism, necromancy, and whatever the frippery of all may be called, have no value at all in order to free man from his own immortality; there is only one way to do this, namely, the attainment of that self-knowledge which makes man immortal.

All such so-called “evidence” can at most serve to point out to man that the possibility of becoming immortal exists, so that he may strive to attain it. The belief that man is immortal, doing as he pleases, is as demoralizing as it is false; the belief that man’s immortality depends upon the willful favor of any third party, which he depends upon beside himself, brings no answer.

The sages of all peoples and of all times have taught that there is something in man which is immortal, and that the man who comes to the knowledge of this immortal being within him thereby becomes a partaker of its immortality.

This immortal being was referred to by various names, such as “God,” “Brahma,” “Chu” (Egyptian), “Atma,” “Christos” and so on. Meister Eckhart, Jakob Boehme etc. call it the “divine spark” in the human soul, others call it “divine love,” others “divine self-knowledge.”

It is the self-consciousness of God in man, the light which, if illuminating the soul, makes it immortal. It is “the Father,” the sacred fire (Ātmā), to which none (manas) can come except through the “Flame” (Buddhi), “the Son,” and the power by which this is done is the Light of divine self-knowledge, “the holy spirit.”




The soulness ones

Now there are people of different kinds, namely:

People who have no spark of this divine love within them. These are only humanoid creatures; in appearance they are human-like, perhaps even well-trained and learned, sharp-witted, cunning, etc., but have no trace of genius or real spirit; they are only human animals and not immortal.

The vast majority of people who are born with this divine spark within them, but in whom it lies dormant and will sooner or later, though not during their present existence on earth, come to awaken. The degree to which they can enjoy the consciousness of their immortality depends on the degree to which they feel this existence (the presence of God within them).

People in whom, as a result of their vices or perverted desires, the feeling and awareness of this divine spark has been totally lost, “ungodly,” that is, those in which this divine (Ātmā Buddhi) has separated from the earthly being (Manas-Kāma), never to return. These are the spiritually dead for whom there is no awakening because the ability for spiritual recognition has been lost in them.

Despite their astuteness and piousness, they are irretrievably lost if this divine spark does not return to their hearts through a complete reversal, which is only possible as long as they still have a trace of the divine within themselves.


With regard to these spiritually deceased, Chauncey Giles says:

“Physical death, that is, the death of the human body, is a beneficent arrangement in nature, a means by which man can attain his higher destiny (on the path of evolution).

But there is another death, which is not in purpose the divine order, but opposed to it, and by which the destruction of humanity in man’s nature and the impossibility of his salvation are brought about. This is the spiritual death which can take place before the body dies.

A great “spiritual” (intellectual) unfolding of the natural mind (Manas-Kama) can take place without any trace of divine love (self-knowledge) being associated with it. Whoever sinks into selfishness and love of the world and its pleasures loses love of God (his Divine Self, i.e. truth) and his fellow men.

He sinks from life (the higher consciousness) into death (the pseudo-animal consciousness).

The higher principles, which constitute the essential elements of his humanity, leave him, and he lives only at the level of his human earthly activity. Physically (and intellectually) he is there, but spiritually he is dead.

To all, which pertains to the higher and alone immortal existence, he is as dead as his body will be dead to all sensual and worldly enjoyments and pleasures when the spirit (prāṇa) will have left him.

This spiritual death is the result of a way of life contrary to the laws of the (Divine) Spirit in nature, which has the same consequences on the spiritual level as disobedience to the laws of physical nature on the physical plane.

At least the mentally dead have their amusements. They have their intellectual abilities and powers and may be intensely intellectually active. All animal faculties are in their possession, and for the majority of people these are the highest ideal of their happiness.

These living-dead, intoxicated by the indefatigable thirst for wealth, by the pleasures and amusements of social life, may cultivate elegance of appearance and demeanor, seek social favor and scholarly distinction; but with all their charms, proud robes, and resplendent attributes, these hollow creatures are dead in the eyes of the “Lord” (Īśvara), and when measured by the only correct and unchanging standard (truth), such creatures have in reality no more life than a skeleton whose flesh has become dust and earth.”


All such views we have heard from the pulpit during our youth, but it is one thing to make such statements in a dogmatic manner and require the hearers to give the same blind faith, and it is another to explain such doctrines scientifically and make it tangible.

Anyone who is used to believing blindly and letting the pastor think for themselves has it easy, they have no doubts and ultimately no knowledge either. But the self-thinking man encounters the objections of his reason everywhere, he would always like to know the “how” and “why” before he decides to believe. He wants to understand something theoretically before following it practically.

This purpose is fulfilled by the theosophical teaching as we find it in the ancient scriptures of the Indians. Where the Bible merely tells us, “This and that you must do,” the Vedas give the reason why.

According to these, the separation of Kāma-manas from Ātmā-buddhi-manas is a possibly occurring event during life, and the study of the “seven principles” in man’s constitution gives the key to its explanation.

In the end, some of our today astonished celebrities are nothing but an elemental — an “earth spirit”!

 (Lotusblüten 3, no. 17, February 1893, pp. 125-134)
 





OBSERVATIONS

If you are not familiar with Theosophical teachings, you will find it difficult to understand the dissertation that Franz Hartmann wrote. That is why I am going to clarify it for you.

Theosophical instructors reported that humans are composed of seven principles, which are:

  • The divine spirit (Atma)
  • The spiritual soul (Buddhi)
  • The mental one (Manas)
  • The body of passions and desires (Kama)
  • The energetic body (Prana)
  • The astral body (Linga Sarira)
  • The physical body (Sthūla Sarira)

The three superior beings are immortal, while the four inferior beings are mortal, meaning they die at the end of each reincarnation and must be rebuilt at the beginning of the next reincarnation.

Some individuals, due to various circumstances, mainly because they sink deeper and deeper into evil or vice, sever the energetic connection that unites them with their higher triad.

These individuals are called 'soulless people' because they are no longer connected to their higher self. Outwardly they appear to be normal humans, but at a vibrational level they have become separated from their connection to the divine, and consequently are destined to disappear.

And this disintegration is what theosophical instructors call 'true death'.