Dr. Jirah Dewey Buck was a homeopathic physician and a prominent leader in the early American Theosophical movement.
Dr. Franz Hartmann met him when he went to the United States in 1897 to give a lecture tour on theosophy in various cities of that country.
They became friends and I will now translate the letters that I have found that Hartmann wrote to Buck, adding my explanations to clarify the events that Hartmann narrates in them.
LETTER OF 1897
« Hallein, October 17, 1897.
My dear Dr. Buck.
I received your delightful letter and thank you very much for the kind sentiments expressed therein. I should also be very glad to send you a baril of Lignosulfot [a medicine invented by Hartmann] free of any charge; but unfortunately I am bound by contract with Mr. Parmele and Dr. Buckman, not to send any either directly or indirectly to America until they have decided what to do about it, by January 1, 1897.
I hope however that you will obtain some by writing to Dr. Buckman, Fort Wayne, Ind. or by addressing Chas. Boone Parmele, 36 Platt Street, New York.
Here we have wonderful and often entirely unexpected success with it. The worst cases of eczema are cured by washing with L.s. and a patient at the inhalatorium whowes blind on one eye, while inhaling for his bronchial catarrh, unexpectedly recovered his sight. Professor Leyden of Berlin highly recommended it at the medical congress at Moskau, and now everything promises to go well.
I received a letter from a friend of yours from Denver, and advised him to write to Parmele. I am now getting ready to lecture on Theosophy in Austria and Germany and next week I will lecture at Vienna. If the L.s. Comp. gets started in America, I hope to see you next year. I shall then, I hope, not be "managed" by Mr. Willard but manage myself.
I am having a great deal of trouble with this Theosophical Society business in this country, owing to the continued fussing and fighting about the superiority of Mrs. Tingley or Mrs. Besant, and am sick of this presideney and sick of all partisanship.
I wish we could have in Germany a real Theosophical Society based upon the recognition of truth, and not founded merely upon a belief in the superiority of this or that person. For this reason I have started an International Theosophical Brotherhood (without knowing anything about Mrs. Tingleys similar scheme). This I.T.B. to be the large circle to which everybody may belong, whether he believes in Tingley or Besant, the inner circle to be the active members of the Theosophical Society in Germany.
This I.T.B. to be free in the administration of its own affairs from any foreign Society.
This seems to have been misunderstood by Mrs. Tingley and Neresheimer, as if I wanted a separation from the T.S. in A., although I expressly declared my adherence to the T.S. in A. at our convention. So Mrs. T. & N. sent a "protest", which shows a quite sectarian spirit, and by which they have made a bad impression in Germany.
I prefer to say nothing about it, and to let matters take their own course; but I thought it well, to inform you about the state of the matter.
I wish to the T. S. in A. the greatest possible financial success, and I gave to Mr. Pierce and Mrs. Tingley a large share in the Lignosulfot Co. for that purpose; but I should be sorry if the people in that country should get the impression that the T. S. in A. was a mere money-making scheme.
Elease give my love and regards to your family, If you have time to write, I should be very glad to hear from you. My permanent address is for the present Hallein in Salzburg, Austria.
Later on I return to Florence.
Yours Faithfully
Dr. F. Hartmann »
Observations
After Blavatsky died in 1891, the Theosophical Movement had three great leaders:
- William Judge in America.
- Annie Besant in Europe.
- And Colonel Olcott in Asia.
Unfortunately, shortly afterwards Besant and Olcott joined forces to expel William Judge, and the result was that in 1895 the Theosophical Society split into two organizations:
1) The Theosophical Society of America led by William Judge and
2) The Theosophical Society of Adyar led by Olcott and Besant.
William Judge died shortly after this breakup, and Katherine Tingley became the new president of the Theosophical Society of America.
She appointed Hartmann president of the German section of the Theosophical Society of America, and Hartmann had to deal with the confrontation between the supporters of Tingley and the supporters of Besant.
Fed up with this situation, Hartmann created the "International Theosophical Brotherhood" organization, which was intended to not take part in these partisan disputes and to include both sides, but the result was that both sides became angry with him.
Sadly, both Besant and Tingley did a lot of damage to the Theosophical Movement.
POSTCARD FROM 1898
« Gruss aus Hallein. January 14, 1898.
Dr. J.:
Accept my congratulation to the success of the Chicago convention. I am very glad that you have been elected. I hope that in this country too harmony will be restored before long. With my sincere regards, to you and your family.
Yours truly,
F.H. »
LETTER OF 1900
FRANZ HARTMANN, MD
VILLA MERCEDES, BELLO SGUARDO
FIRENZE
« Florence, Jan 9, 1900.
My dear Dr. Buck:
Many thanks for your kind and interesting letter. I do not understand why your letter to Hallein has not reached unless you addressed it to Hullein which is another place. There are however two Halleins in Austria.
I have been very much interested in what you wrote me about Hilarion and the Lodge in Syracuse, and I should, as a matter of course, be very glad to participate in it, but as I am here in Europe, this would perhaps be somewhat difficult.
I suppose that my participation will have to be a spiritual one and consist in harmonious thought and sympathy. Any paper that you will send, will however be welcome and kept secret.
I to have heard nothing more of the E.S. [Esoteric Section] of which Charles Johnstone seems to be the "outer head", and I do not know whether I belong to any "esoteric section" except my own, which is presided over by my inner consciousness.
It always seems me that each "esoteric Society", as soon as it steps on the external plane, become exoteric, and then follows sectarianism and intolerance, such as is exhibited by the members of the Tingley and Besant persuasion.
The latter have gone so far as to warn my own most intimate friends against me and prohibit them from reading my books. There is only one all saving Theosophical Society, whose president is Capt. Bumptious [Olcott], and whose oracel is Mrs. Besant.
Last year I gave a lecture at Nice (France) with great success, but none of the Besant people were permitted to attend, the Countess Wachtmeister would not allow it, although I and my friends have come to her lecture (which was a very poor one).
Last night I gave a lecture in Italian language in Florence, and had a very nice audience; but Mrs. Cooper-Oakley warned her adherents to attend, and thereby she disgusted her own best followers, who thereupon left her society.
Is to in it to be wondered, when under such circumstances I am disgusted with all this childish nonsense and "Theosophical Society business"?
I prefer to deal with sensible people, who do not belong to anything except to themselves, fooling with society fanatics, who consider everyone their enemy, if he does not cling to the coat tails of the same person as they.
There is not one person a hundred ripe for entering a real esoteric society, nevertheless we have now a lot of such bodies assuming that name, and consisting of curiosity hunters each of which desires to ursurp the leadership in the T.S., while in fact the T.S. requires no other leader, but the light of truth, and ought to remain, what always was intended to be, a body for free investigation of the laws which govern the universe.
Practically the efforts of Mrs. Besant and Mrs. Tingley have been to turn the whole T.S. into an "esoteric Society", each under her sole leadership, and thus they have succeeded in turning it into one great insane asylum, where the brothers and sisters heartily hate and despise each other if they do not belong to the same party.
I have succeeded to form quite a number of theosophical societies on the original plan in Germany, Austria and Hungaria, but I am adverse to bringing them under one hat, because I wish to avoid all tendency to sectarianism and prefer that each society should be independent and stand on its own legs. For the same reason I have refused all offers to be elected president.
I agree that each esoteric society must have as leader a spiritually elevated person, with whom all the members ought to be as one in thought and aspiration, so that he may carry them up with him into the regions of knowledge, and for this reason a disciple cannot have more than ome master. No one can at the same time go two different ways.
But all this has nothing to do with the T.S. because the T.S. is no esoteric society and not a school for occultism, but a preparatory school in which each member should first of all try to learn to find his own real self. If he has found himself, he will not have far to go to for a master for aid and instruction.
With all this, I cannot say that I regret or deplore all this strive and discension in the T.S. I do not pretend to be wiser than the law of Karma, which has ordered it and which leads everything to the best end.
Nothing has done so much to call the attention to the theosophical teachings as the opposition of the missionaries and the slader of the Society of Psychical Research. From opposition grows strength.
Let the members of the T. S. become so much sectarian as they please; there are always some who will get experience and outgrow their sectarianism in time, and they are the only ones which are worth having. I should be glad if these views should become known.
Please give my love and regards to your family and to our friends in Syracuse.
I shall always be glad to hear from you.
Yours very sincerely,
F. Hartmann
Postscript: I have not received the "Forum" last month. »
Observations
In this letter, Hartmann explains how those two factions became increasingly sectarian and adversarial. But what Hartmann failed to realize was that the group led by Besant was increasingly straying from the original teachings due to the lies that Alfred Sinnett and Charles Leadbeater were introducing.
As for the Esoteric Section, it was a parallel school to the Theosophical Society, which Blavatsky had created to give a preliminary start to theosophists who wanted to become disciples of the Masters in the future.
But unfortunately, after Blavatsky's death, Annie Besant increasingly altered this esoteric school until it became a complete farce.
